New SAR Activity Review Details Trends, Tips & Issues by Mary Beth Guard
Ever wonder how many Suspicious Activity Reports are filed each year? What is done with them? What trends they reveal? Wonder no more! A new report published under the auspices of the Bank Secrecy Act Advisory Group answers those questions and many more. Project co-chairpersons John Byrne, Senior Counsel and Compliance Manager at ABA, and David Vogt, Assistant Director of FinCEN, unveiled the new report on Monday, October 30, 2000, during a money laundering conference held in Washington. D.C. The full report is available on the FinCEN site. (See Related Links below)
We've studied the report and extracted the highlights for you.
The number of SARs filed has steadily risen each year, from 49,786 in 1996 to 120,506 in 1999. Through the end of August, 100,353 SARs had been filed in 2000.
California leads the way in SAR filings by a significant margin, with 27,354 for the first eight months of 2000. New York follows with 11,710 for the same period. The next five states, in order, are Florida, Texas, Illinois, Arizona, and Pennsylvania.
In terms of the type of suspicious activity reported, BSA/Structuring/Money Laundering ranks highest, constituting 45.3% of all SAR filings since 1996, followed by check fraud, 13.15%. Among other types of suspicious activity reported in significant numbers are counterfeit checks, defalcation/embezzlement, credit card fraud, check kiting, false statements, consumer loan fraud and mortgage loan fraud.
National banks have filed far more SARs than their state-chartered counterparts. Thus far in 2000, institutions with the OCC as their primary regulator filed 59,299 SARS, while those who have the Federal Reserve or FDIC as their primary federal regulator have filed a combined total of 24,608.
In terms of trends spotted in SARs filed in 2000, the report notes l) several complexes of activity involving suspicious wire transfer patterns; 2) possible reflections of Russian criminal activity; 3) increased SAR reporting involving Mexico; and 4) a continuing trend in suspicious transactions in which funds are wired to/through a U.S. financial institution from a foreign source and then withdrawn in cash in a third country using ATMs.
The report gives several examples of law enforcement cases in which SARs and other BSA information played an important role in a successful investigation and/or prosecution of criminal financial activity. The types of criminal schemes uncovered include:
a $28 million investment fraud scheme;
a massive scheme to embezzle approximately $2.7 million from a South Dakota college;
customs fraud;
fraud involving the opening of accounts under aliases into which were deposited counterfeit commercial checks. Funds were wired from the accounts to Nigeria prior to the time the bank learned the deposited items were counterfeit;
smuggling of stolen luxury vehicles from the U.S. into Europe by a Russian and Lithuanian organized crime group;
repackaging and exportation of stolen commercial baby formula;
money laundering by officers of a check cashing company;
an elaborate conspiracy which including bilking millions of dollars worth of goods from a food bank, burning buildings for insurance, stalking, and trying to corrupt the judicial system;
a worker's compensation scam totaling more than $3 million dollars;
stock fraud targeting the elderly;
a marijuana selling ring in Kentucky that laundered $5.9 million in drug proceeds;
the largest Medicaid fraud case in the nation.
The report provides five substantive tips for SAR Form Preparation & Filing:
The narrative section of the SAR should provide a detailed description of the known or suspected violation of law or suspicious activity;
Supporting documentation should never be attached to a SAR form, but the actual documentation should be maintained on file for a minimum period of five years;
Filers are encouraged to adopt and utilize a standardized format for identifying the reporting organizing on the SAR, using the organization's name (in a consistent manner), and EIN, along with a complete address;
Always identify your primary regulator on a SAR;
Use whole dollar amounts in the space "total dollar amount involved in known or suspicious activity.
Guidance was given on four additional issues:
organizations should report continuing suspicious activity with a report being filed at least every 90 days;
whether an account should be closed as the result of the identification of suspicious activity is a determination the institution should make, but just because an SAR has been filed, that should not be the basis, by itself, for terminating a customer relationship. Confer with counsel and senior staff to make a decision about closing an account;
An SAR must be filed no more than 30 calendar days from the date of detection of the suspicious activity unless a suspect cannot be identified, in which case the time period is extended to 60 days. The time period begins to run when the institution reaches the point where it knows, or has reason to suspect, that the activity or transactions meet the reporting standards;
The law prohibits the notification of any person that is involved in the activity being reported on a SAR that the activity has been reported. If an organization receives a subpoena or court order seeking a SAR, it should contact its primary supervisor and FinCEN for direction and guidance.
For more information about Bank Secrecy Act issues, use our search engine to locate the wealth of articles we have on the subject, using BSA-related search terms and phrases.
For BSA links (including the statute, regulations, advisories, forms and more), click over to the Compliance Launch Pad.
First published November 2, 2000. Copyright, 2000, BankersOnline. All rights reserved.
BankersOnline is a free service made possible by the generous support of our
advertisers and sponsors. Advertisers and sponsors are not responsible for site content. Please help us keep BankersOnline FREE to all
banking professionals. Support our advertisers and sponsors by clicking
through to learn more about their products and services.