I'm hoping Casey James... clothing optional.

who is Angie?

I'm actually really excited about Stones week.. a lot to work with.

they would have much to work with if they did MC5 also....

The whole purpose of the Rolling Stones theme is to make more money for the Rolling Stones. Thus the "sample list of songs" on iTunes".

I'm hoping to hear Siobhan do Sympathy for the Devil.

I'm hoping Adam Lambert makes an appearance this season and screeches like a stuck pig.

Somehow I doubt he will. Too much fear of teh ghey on primetime TV.

Naw, if he doesn't, it's not because he's gay. He was gay on the show. It's because he's gone over the top and left AI Pop behind for uberdrama.

I think he's just too much of a risk on primetime. His Grammy performance marked him as a huge liability.

Really? I'm thinking she could make something cool out of Paint it Black. She, Crystal, Casey, and Lee are the only ones who *might* not completely butcher Stones.

I'm expecting to hear Lee do Paint in Black.

I don't think Adam officially came out until after the show was over.

Anyway, David Cook and Ke$sha are slated to sing tonight.

(well, that's per wiki)

He was never "in". The fans sites talked about it plenty from day 1. They made it public on the show near the very end in a conversation with the guy who beat him out in the finals.

I think Lily could have done RS too. Alas, she's gone

I am with Becca 100% on Siobhan doing Paint It Black. That was the very first thing that came to my mind as well.

They should really rename this show, "American How Dull".

Now you're talking. "Kick out the jams, mother******!"

What did everyone think last night? I was completely underwhelmed by all of them, but I am not a Rolling Stones fan, so I was unfamiliar with probably half the songs.

Lee needs to learn to enunciate just a bit when he is singing. I thought most of his song was pretty unintelligible.

I liked Siobhan, Didi, Casey, and Andrew the best. Aaron was better last night than I expected him to be. Probably the worst in my opinion was Tim Urban. I think Paige, Katie and Lacy could go at any time, too.

I really liked that kid's version of Angie.

I also enjoyed Siobhan, Didi, and Casey.

I did not like Big Mike for some reason.

I think your going home at any time choices are right on!

On the whole, they did better than I expected.

Siobhan rocked!
Crystal was amazing, as always.
Casey was good.
Lee was good - his nerves are getting the better of him.
Mike & Didi - meh. Not impressive, but not bad.
Katie can sing, but something about her bugs me.
The rest can go home any time now.

Did anyone else notice that Aaron Kelly's mom's name is Kelly Kelly!

No, but I did notice that she said, "We adopted Aaron at age five." and then he said, "I don't know where I get it, my mom certainly can't sing."

Yeah, I heard him say that too!