And what about Tim?

Don't hold back now!!

Tim? There's a guy named Tim?

He can go home next week. For the love of bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwiches let Paige go home tonight!

Paige was so bad it was embarrassing.

They should have said "forget voting this week, paige is going home"

embarrasing, perhaps


good TV that allows me to laugh at the misfortune of others, absolutely!

Yeah, but that stage of the show is supposed to be over. Imagine a game show where just before the final answer they reset the scores to 0!

in my book, there is always time for some kind of embarrassing moments...........I'm sick that way

As I'm sure a lot of you do, we always offer our own critique of the performances. For everyone who sang after Paige, our commentary last night was simply, "Not terrible enough to save Paige!"

The only one I truly loved last night was Crystal.

I loathed Paige (I could've sang better, and I can't carry a tune), Tim (just...ugh) and Andrew.

Mike sang the song well, but the second he sings a fast song again his cheeseball moves are gonna drive me crazy.

I like Didi, but didn't love her performance last night.

Katie is definitely a 'bot', most definitely...

I just watched the performances during my lunch (Love that I can fast forward through all the muck!).

Poor Paige was absolutely awful! Ellen couldn't even comment it was so bad!

I liked Crystal and Didi, but I've been fans of them since the beginning. I liked Michael, but it wasn't my favorite performance of his.

shocking!

I didn't see last night's results coming at all

She didn't even look like she wanted to be there anymore.

The whole time she jsut had that look on her face.

Good riddance!

I thought it was fabulous that Paige, Katie, and Tim were the bottom three. Too bad we couldn't lose them all in one fell swoop.

I was surprised that Miley actually sang her song. I figured she was a lip syncher. Although it wasn't great, I gotta give her props for actually singing. That's rare among today's pop stars.

My favorite part....when Simon told her they wouldn't be saving her, that was great!


kneeling and begging is the next step

America definitely got the bottom two correct. Glad that Paige went home. Tim wasn't good either. Didn't see Katie. Not liking the guy in the bottom row, end, left side - Andrew (?). Not a fan of his at all.

I agree with you Peepers. There was no hope for her and it's good that they told her up front.

And did you notice how Katie-bot copied Crystal's answer...

she keeps it up and I-Robot may become a reality

I love crystal's confidence...she manages to pull it off without sounding/looking sassy.....maybe that's why she seems to much better, she's not working to figure out the judges..she's just performing?

the "right" bottom 3 could have been any number of combos this week....totally OK with Paige going home.

There's only five of 'em that are worthy of performing anymore

1.Crystal
2.Casey
3.Big Mike
4.Siobhan
5.Lee

Ranked in order of how good I think they are at this stage of the game.

Crystal is the Vegas Odds winner right now.

I agree with you!

So no comments from anyone yet about the WONDERFUL group song performance of that Wham classic, "Wake Me Up Before You Go Go"???? Talk about issues with song choices, perhaps the folks at Idol should listen a little bit more to what the judges have to say on that topic!

I can't even watching the group performances anymore.