But nothing in the original post says it was multi-family nor that the borrower was not a natural person. George, your exception works if one or both of those are applicable, but what if neither are applicable?
LTC, it sounds like the credit analyts considered both the project gross revenue and the borrower's gross income in making the decision, so I would say if it is a natural person borrower on a 1-4 family rental property, I'd use combined numbers. I'd want to document the file as to why I made that decision, though and I'd want to be consistent with reporting similar properties.
_________________________
Jim Bedsole, CRCM, CBA, CFSA, CAFP
My posts - my opinions