We too plan to limit geographically to our region. We are a smaller community bank serving a few counties in the Midwest. We also will use out of wallet questions, which we know aren't fool proof. In a true identity theft situation, there's a good possibility that the fraudster will be able to successfully answer those questions. In addition like you said GilaMonster, a legitimate person could fail the OOWQ.
rlcarey, I understand your point, but I can't image we will have customer satisfaction if we require them to come in person to validate their account/themselves. My wife and I have opened deposit, credit card, and college savings plans all online, never once set foot inside a building to finalize it.
I personally think it's a risk that the FI's need to address, risk assess, and determine if it is something they need to move forward with.