If we re-use the information on an existing credit report, are we required to send the customer a new credit score notice?

(For customers who get small dollar amount loans more than once a year, we only run their credit report once every 12 months, if needed)

There is no regulatory support for re-using an existing credit report. Your credit bureau contract likely disallows it also.

In addition to what Randy states I am not aware of any exemption for not providing the disclosure if a credit score is used for the credit transaction even if it is from a previously obtained report.

The purpose of the disclosure is to inform the consumer of the score used and when it was generated.