Skip to content
BOL Conferences
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4
Thread Options Tools
#50703 - 12/26/02 06:37 PM Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Anonymous
Unregistered

We have a customer who is making a very large (almost 6 figure) cash withdrawal, and has informed the bank rep that he is opening up a safe deposit box and putting the cash in there. Once this transaction takes place (I know that we should not know what is going in the box, but we are not deaf), is a SAR warranted? We will be filing a CTR. (He also asked about insurance we have on our boxes !!!)

Return to Top
General Discussion
#50704 - 12/26/02 06:41 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Andy_Z Offline
10K Club
Andy_Z
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 27,748
On the Net
More and more banks are now posting notices that safe deposit box contents are NOT insured. Once that cash leaves the account it is not even FDIC insured.

And while I've heard "banking myths" that cash in a SD box is illegal, I've never read it. No SAR, nothing illegal.
_________________________
AndyZ CRCM
My opinions are not necessarily my employers.
R+R-R=R+R
Rules and Regs minus Relationships equals Resentment and Rebellion. John Maxwell

Return to Top
#50705 - 12/26/02 06:51 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Don_Narup Offline

Power Poster
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 3,708
Las Vegas Nevada
It shouldn't make any difference to the bank where the customer decides to keep their cash. They could just as well keep it a can in the back yard. Is that suspecius or eccentric? However, If a customer has no qualms in telling bank staff they keep cash in the box, be careful.

Not that they will do it, but its an open door for a law suite stating someone in the bank took money out of it. Be sure there are no exceptions your safe deposit procedures for anyone.

As he has made it known, I would tell him because of that it woud be best if he took a box somewhere else.

Andy's suggestion of the sign is a great idea. Make sure your customer knows that.
_________________________
Compliance Analysis and Research - Software for your CRA/HMDA analysis needs

Return to Top
#50706 - 12/26/02 07:11 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Ann Offline
Platinum Poster
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 564
South Carolina
Check out this training course on BOL. It looks like some good and timely information.

My opinions are my own and not those of my employer.

Return to Top
#50707 - 12/26/02 09:26 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Bear Collector, CRCM Offline
Diamond Poster
Bear Collector, CRCM
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 1,830
District of Columbia
While there are no laws that I am aware of regarding where a customer keeps his/her cash, I think the filing of a SAR might not be so far-fetched. According to an article I read, your institution does have an obligation to watch for any suspicious behavior. Staff should be trained to look for suspicious patterns of activity in or around safe-custody areas. They should have a process to follow if they observe any such suspicious activity. If this customer is announcing that he is placing large sums of cash in his safe deposit box, my first question would be "Why?". If the answer doesn't make sense, it could be anything from stupidity to tax evasion to terrorism. If in doubt, I'd file.
Leslie
_________________________
Being kind is more important than being important.

Return to Top
#50708 - 12/26/02 09:44 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
BANNED BY BOL MANAGEMENT Offline
Platinum Poster
BANNED BY BOL MANAGEMENT
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 524
I'll vote no on the SAR, as a CTR is being filed and just because a customer states that cash is going into a safe deposit box does not mean that it is. In addition, the fact that there is no law against placing currency is a safe deposit box should prompt no action, report wise.

There is no logic to reporting the safe deposit activity, since the customer is electing to secure currency in a safe deposit box, versus walking out the door with a bundle of cash – that’s just a smart thing to do. Since you, I assuming, would not prepare an SAR based on the customer walking out the door with the cash, it follows that placing the cash in a safe deposit box would not warrant reporting.

Return to Top
#50709 - 12/26/02 10:02 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Bear Collector, CRCM Offline
Diamond Poster
Bear Collector, CRCM
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 1,830
District of Columbia
Grist,
Before I posted my reply, I checked with our BSA Offocer and asked her if a SAR should be filed in the circumstances stated by the original poster. She felt that it could be suspicious, and as such, should be reported. Truthfully, a customer walking out the door with large sums of cash on a regular basis could also be suspicious and reportable.
Before Y2K, we had a lot of customers who were uneasy about the banking system placing their cash in their safe deposit boxes, or converting it into multiple cashier's checks. That was not really suspicious, given the circumstances at the time. I think you just need to judge each scenario on its own merit and decide whether it is prudent to file.
Leslie
_________________________
Being kind is more important than being important.

Return to Top
#50710 - 12/26/02 10:12 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Anonymous
Unregistered

I tend to agree that anyone withdrawing a large amount of cash from an interest bearing account protected by FDIC insurance and placing it into a safe deposit box is highly unusual, bordering on suspicious. The regulators are really looking for banks to report anything they deem as suspicious. Who is to say what is suspicious. The fact that the branch called the Security Dept. lets you know that the branch thought there was something unusual about the situation. I think if you asked a regulator their opinion, they'd say "File". Any regulators out there want to anonymously voice your opinion ???

Return to Top
#50711 - 12/26/02 10:16 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Richard Insley Offline
10K Club
Richard Insley
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 10,179
Toano, VA
Leslie- Unless you have something else to go along with "customer has a bag full of cash", a SAR will be a waste of law enforcement's time. Cash is legal tender and anyone can have as much as s/he can legally acquire. SARs are "value-added" reports. Cash alone is not suspicious--and even if a particular cash event IS suspicious, what SUA do you suspect?

These kinds of SARs are the cholesterol of the BSA reporting system.
_________________________
...gone fishing.

Return to Top
#50712 - 12/26/02 10:47 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Michelle M Offline
Gold Star
Michelle M
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 422
I would have to agree with Rich. Although I would concider it a stupid (yes, I said STUPID)move to make, a lot of people are worried about banks going under after 9-11 and the Enron thing, so maybe this guy is thinking, "It's REALLY safe cause it's in the vault AND it's cash." So if the bank goes under he's totally covered.

You may think it's suspicious because you'd never do that, but after 9-11 we had a few people come in says "My friend told me I should take all my money out of the bank..."
_________________________
Michelle M Opinions do not necessarily reflect those of my employer nor are they legal advice

Return to Top
#50713 - 12/26/02 11:10 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Andy_Z Offline
10K Club
Andy_Z
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 27,748
On the Net
What is the basic suspicion, he has a lot of cash?

When we had a customer want over $100K in cash we had an off duty cop there to escort him off our property. The cop thought we were weird because this is common in that part of the state. Well, while it would be common for me. it wasn't suspicious, just irregular.
_________________________
AndyZ CRCM
My opinions are not necessarily my employers.
R+R-R=R+R
Rules and Regs minus Relationships equals Resentment and Rebellion. John Maxwell

Return to Top
#50714 - 12/26/02 11:47 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
BANNED BY BOL MANAGEMENT Offline
Platinum Poster
BANNED BY BOL MANAGEMENT
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 524
I'm not convinced. You are basically saying that every customer that prompts the filing of a CTR will also have a SAR filed on them as they walk out the door. Your suspicion: They not only withdraw the cash, but the walked out with the cash!

All the regulators need to know is that the customer withdrew cash and it's none of our business (at the bank level) what they do with it, it's a matter for the government to sort out.

If you take your scenario one step further, if the same customer deposits the same cash back to their account you would naturally file a CTR and, in your world, a SAR.

Return to Top
#50715 - 12/27/02 12:04 AM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Bear Collector, CRCM Offline
Diamond Poster
Bear Collector, CRCM
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 1,830
District of Columbia
I do not think (nor did I state) that EVERY cash transaction is suspicious. What I said was that I beleive you have to look at each situation and judge it on its own merits. According to The U.S. Suspicious Activity Reporting regulations, FinCEN requires that "every bank" file with Treasury "a report of any suspicious transaction relevant to a possible violation of law or regulation." The SAR regulations define a "suspicious transaction" as any transaction involving $5,000 or more that is "conducted or attempted by, at, or through the bank... and the bank knows, suspects, or has reason to suspect that":

* "The transaction involves funds derived from illegal activities or is intended or conducted in order to hide or disguise funds or assets derived from illegal activities… as part of a plan to violate or evade any federal law or regulation or to avoid any transaction reporting requirement under federal law or regulation"

* "The transaction is designed to evade any requirements of this part or of any other regulations promulgated under the Bank Secrecy Act..."

* "The transaction has no business or apparent lawful purpose or is not the sort in which the particular customer would normally be expected to engage, and the bank knows of no reasonable explanation for the transaction after examining the available facts, including the background and possible purpose of the transaction."

I still believe that in the safe deposit scenario, the bank must determine if this is normal, everyday activity, or if this is something designed for an unlawful purpose such as to evade taxes. As I stated in my first response to this post, I would want to know WHY the client chose to place huge amounts of money in his SD box before jumping to any conclusions. Maybe he is hiding money from a greedy ex-wife, or maybe he just doesn't like banks. I just do not think the bank can turn a blind eye when something is this unususal. (and obviously the original poster thought it was unususal, or he/she would not have asked the question!)
Leslie
_________________________
Being kind is more important than being important.

Return to Top
#50716 - 12/27/02 04:36 AM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
JacF Offline

Power Poster
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 6,719
PA
In reply to:

and the bank knows of no reasonable explanation for the transaction after examining the available facts, including the background and possible purpose of the transaction



It has been my experience that sometimes the direct approach is the best way to get the answer to this one. Perhaps the customer is doing something that he thinks makes good financial sense, and is willing to share his reasoning. I would not file a SAR on this one without first asking the customer for an explanation- which can benefit the bank both from a BSA standpoint and a customer service standpoint. Cash in safe deposit boxes is probably more common than we would like to believe. I've even drilled boxes for non-payment of rent and found enough cash to cover the rent.

Return to Top
#50717 - 12/27/02 12:06 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Richard Insley Offline
10K Club
Richard Insley
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 10,179
Toano, VA
In reply to:

I beleive you have to look at each situation and judge it on its own merits




Exactly right, Leslie!

Detection of a strange cash transaction would simply arouse my curiosity. The regs give me "30 calendar days after the date of initial detection by the bank of facts that may constitute a basis for filing a SAR." During this 30 days I will monitor further transactions, review other information, and possibly talk to the customer. At any point during my investigation I could develop the additional facts that would tip the balance in favor of a SAR. If, at the end of my investigation, there's nothing more than cash going into a safe deposit box, I would not file a SAR.
_________________________
...gone fishing.

Return to Top
#50718 - 12/27/02 02:07 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Anonymous
Unregistered

I have also been involved in many safe deposit drillings and in the past I have asked council if we should be filing a CTR/SAR for these type of transactions. The attorney did say that (within reason) customers can put what ever they like into their safe deposit box. I once had a customer from Thailand who couldn't wait to show me the contents of her sd box, there were several artifacts dating back hundreds of years in her family, one of which was a pipe used to smoke cocaine (or some drug). I didn't file anything on her because it was obvious in this situation that it was just an heirloom. I agree with all the previous posts that you really have to look at the situation to determine if it's appropriate to file or not.

Return to Top
#50719 - 12/27/02 02:11 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
E.E.G.B Offline
Power Poster
E.E.G.B
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 6,726
the sandy shore
Opium, probably, don't you think, rather than cocaine? JUST going on my reading and film thoughts, not on any personal experience, of course!!!!!!!
_________________________
I disbelieved what he was saying so hard, I probably created an alternate universe where it wasn't true.

Return to Top
#50720 - 12/27/02 02:18 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Anonymous
Unregistered

Opium...yes, that was it. Sorry, I couldn't remember. The coffee hasn't kicked in yet...it was the coolest pipe i'd ever seen...it was ivory and carved into a monkey. She used to cook for the branch too...hhhmmm, maybe I should have been suspicious!!!! (sorry, a little friday humor)

Return to Top
#50721 - 12/27/02 02:20 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
E.E.G.B Offline
Power Poster
E.E.G.B
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 6,726
the sandy shore
Mmmmmm, Thai cooking. I really like Thai. We may have to get takeout for dinner tonight. There's a place here that does killer Pad Thai to go.
_________________________
I disbelieved what he was saying so hard, I probably created an alternate universe where it wasn't true.

Return to Top
#50722 - 12/27/02 02:25 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Anonymous
Unregistered

Imagine the discussion over dinner..."what made you decide on Thai food tonight, honey? Oh, we were talking about opium at work today..."

Return to Top
#50723 - 12/27/02 02:45 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
E.E.G.B Offline
Power Poster
E.E.G.B
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 6,726
the sandy shore
Given some of the topics that come up at work, I suspect DH would not find that all that unusual! (My BF also works here, so lots of odd topics come up.)
_________________________
I disbelieved what he was saying so hard, I probably created an alternate universe where it wasn't true.

Return to Top
#50724 - 12/27/02 02:50 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
JacF Offline

Power Poster
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 6,719
PA
At least it's not Chinese takeout

Return to Top
#50725 - 12/27/02 02:59 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Kara S Offline
Platinum Poster
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 927
Milwaukee, WI
JacFSB--that was great! Just what I needed to get rolling this wonderful Friday morning.
_________________________
My opinions are not to be construed as legal advice.

Return to Top
#50726 - 12/27/02 03:06 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
Michelle M Offline
Gold Star
Michelle M
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 422
OK that was hilarious.
_________________________
Michelle M Opinions do not necessarily reflect those of my employer nor are they legal advice

Return to Top
#50727 - 12/27/02 03:07 PM Re: Cash In Safe Deposit Box
BANNED BY BOL MANAGEMENT Offline
Platinum Poster
BANNED BY BOL MANAGEMENT
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 524
"The transaction involves funds derived from illegal activities or is intended or conducted in order to hide or disguise funds, etc."

"The transaction is designed to evade any requirements, etc."

"The transaction has no business or apparent lawful purpose, etc.

Telling someone that you are going to put cash into a safe deposit box does not appear to be covered within your post, correct? The "act" of putting cash into a safe deposit box is legal, correct? In my opinion, you are added something to the regulation that just doesn't fit.

Grant you that your liberal interpretation is correct in your mind, but that does not make it correct.

I realize that you did not state that all cash transactions are suspicious, I was just testing your logic.

What if the filing of an SAR became known to the customer and the customer told the story to your local newspaper? Yes, we have an obligation to strictly follow regulations, but customer idiosyncrasy’s are not generally reportable.

Return to Top
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4