The 10 days is now a recommendation, not a requirement. That being said, consistently doing the determination early in the process is best. When I audited banks, I recommended that it be obtained concurrently with the request for value (ordering of the appraisal) OR concurrently with the title search.
Using the "no harm, no foul" system works fine when required insurance can obtained without delaying the loan, but the first time loan closing must be delayed will leave you, at best, with an unhappy borrower. At worst, there may be financial repercussions with the delay.
Also, residential appraisals do not always assign values separately to detached garages, cabanas, etc. You must have a separate policy on each insurable structure. Going back to the appraiser for a revised value may cost something.
Al
_________________________
Al Miller, CRCM
Opinions expressed are my own and not necessarily shared by my employer.