I am working on this same question as to whether or not a deposit account disclosure, ours includes the product information, Reg. E and Reg. CC, when a customer requests a different deposit product. The account number stays the same but the account changes. We have an added challenge because as of January 1st we will be providing specific account information on a simplified "PEW" -like disclosure. The simplified disclosure is not a full deposit account disclosure on its own but does contain all the account information, including features and fees of the specific account. We are trying to determine if we are only required to provide the customer, who is changing account types, the simplified disclosure or the full deposit account disclosure.
I am unclear as to why legal counsel would be the determining factor as to if the full disclosure is required or not. Reg. DD states the disclosure is required when an account is opened. Even though the customer is not opening a new relationship, in essence they are closing one account and obtaining a new account. If they already had an account and later decided to open a second account they would receive the full disclosure. What if the first account was opened 5 years prior and there had been many changes to the account disclosure over that time? Even if they had received Change in Terms notices or Important Information notices alerting them to any negative changes to their account over the years shouldn't they receive a full disclosure according to the rule? Any and all opinions are appreciated.