Answer by Jim Bedsole:
You are under no obligation to provide another card. Especially if you have suffered losses as a result of unauthorized use of the lost cards, you would be entirely within your rights to refuse to issue another card. The customer's only recourse would be to close their account and take their business elsewhere.
Answer by John Burnett:
You are under no obligation to provide another card. Especially if you have suffered losses as a result of unauthorized use of the lost cards, you would be entirely within your rights to refuse to issue another card. The customer's only recourse would be to close their account and take their business elsewhere.