Skip to content

Reg E - Non-Fraud Protection?

Reg E covers fraudulent transactions or unauthorized transactions not conducted by the customer/consumer, but does it provide protection for non-fraud cases? We receive a large amount of disputes where customers have purchased trials or samples from a merchant and are billed a few weeks later for additional products shipped to the consumer. We are under the understanding this is not covered by Reg E as far as provisional credit is concerned, but as long as the customer returns the unwanted products VISA grants a certain amount of protection as long as the customer did what was necessary.

Answer by John Burnett:I take the view that, unless the consumer authorized the transaction in some way (perhaps as part of the agreement to purchase the samples or trials), the charges for the additional products are not authorized and would fall under Reg E's protections for the consumer. If Visa also provides a layer of protection, so much the better. If the consumer did authorize the second shipments then I agree that Reg E error resolution and protection under 205.6 would not be issues.


Answer by Andy Zavoina:It is common that a merchant offers something "for free" which the consumer accepts. In some cases there is a full disclosure that "if you don't cancel by X date, we will ship to and bill you for..." and in some cases it is hidden in the fine print. These claims are made often, but the fact is the consumer agreed to the terms. The customer may regret it later, but it doesn't change the authorization they already gave. Use of a credit card provides more protection for a consumer under Reg Z than they get under Reg E with a debit card. Reg Z is also concerned with consumer satisfaction of products or services purchased. Reg E is only concerned with whether or not the transaction was authorized.

First published on 3/30/09

First published on 03/30/2009

Filed under: 
Filed under technology as: 

Banker Store View All

From training, policies, forms, and publications, to office products and occasional gifts, it’s available here:

Banker Store

hot right now

image description

Looking for effective, convenient training on a particular subject?

BOL Learning Connect offers more than 200 courses ON-DEMAND or on CD ROM from AML to Reg Z and every topic in between.

Search Topics