If the phone number is no longer valid, is there any any other contact info. provided? If not, I would try to contact the customer through other means possible and then verify it was them that applied. I'd want to be VERY sure they are who they say they are.
If I was 100% comfortable it was really them, I would tell them to update the fraud alert info and document the heck out of this. Not a little CYA, but a lot of CYA in this case.
BTW, Happy Birthday.